Penn State trustees spar over emeritus status

mdawson@centredaily.comJuly 12, 2013 


    Highlights from board of trustees committee meetings Thursday:

    • Two trustees will vie Friday for the vice chairman seat of the board: Paul Silvis and Ryan McCombie. Trustee Linda Strumpf backed out during an executive session Thursday.

    • Penn State is proposing a 3.39 tuition increase for first- and second-year students at the University Park campus.

    • A tiff ensues between new trustees and those who’d been on the board before the past two election cycles.

    •  The governance and long-range planning committee will hire a lawyer to conduct an extensive study of governance for the board. The expertise will be in nonprofit and corporation board governance.

— Two former Penn State trustees have been recommended to get the distinctive emeritus status, but the discussion turned into a verbal battle with two trustees who said they think the university should hold off on that until deciding about honoring the late coach Joe Paterno.

The board will vote Friday whether to grant the status to Anne Riley and David Jones, who left the board last year. Riley lost her re-election bid, and Jones decided not to run.

The discussion over the emeritus status came Thursday during a sometimes heated governance committee meeting. The friction, namely between trustees Anthony Lubrano and James Broadhurst, could possibly give a glimpse into head-butting on the horizon over the issues the new slate of trustees parlayed into their election wins.

Lubrano forecast fallout from alumni who’d be upset with the university honoring Riley and Jones after they voted to fire Paterno after the Jerry Sandusky child abuse case rocked the university.

“I think we would be sending the wrong message to our community if we granted them the status,” Lubrano told the committee. “That would be a very bad decision on our part.”

First-year trustee Barbara Doran said she agreed.

But trustee James Broadhurst, who’d been confrontational with Lubrano earlier in the meeting over a separate issue, fought back.

“I feel sorry for the alumni who would be disappointed in this action. I really do,” Broadhurst said.

Broadhurst defended Riley and Jones, telling Lubrano that honoring them and honoring Paterno were squarely different issues.

“We’re talking about trustees,” Broadhurst said, referring to awarding emeritus status. “We’re not talking about distinguished individuals like Joe Paterno or Graham Spanier or Tim Curley.

“This is about something totally different.”

Broadhurst wasn’t the only one spoke up in defense of Riley and Jones.

Trustee Marianne Alexander said it was “unfair to hold these two people hostage to a very serious issue in our alumni community.” She called both “exemplary trustees” and said they met the criteria of serving with distinction.

“Quite frankly, we need their help as emeritus trustees,” she said.

Riley served on the board from 1997 to 2012 and is a retired English teacher at State College Area High School and former university alumni association president. Jones served on the board for the same length of time and was a longtime journalist with The New York Times.

The governance committee’s chairman, Keith Eckel, praised both of the former trustees in a statement released by the university. He said Jones asked tough questions and gave every decision a “thorough analysis.”

He said Riley’s loyalty to Penn State is unparalleled.

“She made many difficult decisions during her years of service and always made the decision based not on her personal preference but what was best for Penn State,” Eckel said.

In another matter, the governance committee will hire a lawyer with governance expertise to help the board move forward with governance reforms, such as the size of the board, its structure and selection. The hiring does not require board approval, as committees can retain counsel, Eckel said.

“These are not simple issues,” said Eckel, who recommended the action. “These issues need to be addressed, in my opinion, with a great deal of study.”

Eckel said he liked the idea of hiring a lawyer so the attorney-client privilege will apply to the work done. He said the lawyer should have expertise in nonprofit and corporate board governance.

He said he also wants to seek out governance expertise from within Penn State.


Centre Daily Times is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service