Fiscal discussion unites generations

By Nick Malawskey

STATE COLLEGE — Stephen Watkins is a 23-year-old student at Penn State. Jo Ward, a 90-year-old resident at Foxdale Village.

In the normal course of events, the two would probably not have sat down to discuss politics, fiscal responsibility or government reforms.

But they did Monday night, as part of an intergenerational discussion on America’s fiscal future.

And while there was not a lot to be cheery about — discussion focused on the rising national debt, government spending and possible alternatives and solutions — Watkins said he did hold out hope for America’s future.

The two were part of one of three panels that discussed aspects of America’s fiscal future. Sponsored by Penn State, Foxdale Village, Generations United and Public Agenda, the groups were a mix of individuals — from 22-year-old Penn State student Ann Mesavage, who was worried about her ability to save for the future, to retiree Ed Klevans, who said he was concerned about the legacy that was being created for his five grandchildren.

Held at Foxdale Village, the discussion was part of a pilot program in intergenerational discussions.

Matt Kaplan, a professor at Penn State, said he was hopeful that the program will be successful and could grow into a nationwide forum for intergenerational dialogue.

“There is a lot of uncertainty and anxiety out there,” Kaplan said. “We’re trying to figure out what is our common agenda.”

For Watkins and Ward’s small group, a common agenda was easier said than agreed upon. Like a microcosm of the larger national picture, the nine-member group debated often over issues.

But there was at least one thing everyone agreed on: “I think we agree that the government spends too much money,” said Ayla Detwiler, a 21- year-old student.

And everyone also agreed that the nation is facing a nearly unprecedented crisis.

But several of those present shared their optimism with the group. Ward, who immigrated to the United States, said she has often been impressed with the “American can-do attitude.”

“I don’t think it has jelled yet, but I think it will,” she said.

After taking part in the discussions, Watkins said there are many challenges facing the nation. But, he said, he was hopeful that average citizens will be able to pull together to make the changes necessary to fix the problems facing the nation.

“It may not take Superman to fix it,” he said. “But it is such a crisis that it sets the stage for a superhero to emerge.”

Nick Malawskey can be reached at 235-3928.