Bellefonte took the early lead but failed to find the back of the net again in a 2-1 overtime loss to Juniata on Thursday.
“(We) just couldn’t finish that last goal,” coach Scott Martz said.
Nate Shippee scored to put the Red Raiders ahead 1-0 in the 24th minute. Juniata tied it on a goal by Brand Brackbill six minutes later.
Juniata’s Noah Burns then scored the game-winning goal four minutes into overtime.
Matt Feldman made nine saves for Bellefonte (8-3-2).